Advertisement
Total Articles 5

09

2011-Aug

Golden Ears Measurements F.A.Q.

Nick Name: Golden Ears Registered Date: Aug 09, 2011, 11:26:34 IP ADRESS: *.37.113.239 Views: 40106

Golden Ears Measurements FAQ

 

 

Q) Why do measurements from Golden Ears disagree with data from other websites?

A) The raw data of earphones and headphones are unique to each measuring equipment. And this sort of raw data is different from what we actually hear - which necessitates some calibration to shape the data into what is perceived. At GE, we do this by taking the Diffuse Sound Field and the Room EQ into account, but the method of calibration varies between websites.

 

 

Q) Which data is more accurate?

A) This is not a good question since what we mean by a 'flat' sound signature is not set in stone for the reasons that are discussed below. That is, because both the measured data and how to display them depend on setup, calibration and methodolgy, there isn't a single right answer.

 

 

Q) So you have random, arbitrary standards?

A) While there might not be a single right answer, some answers are more right than others. At GE, we measure and display according to the following standard:

 

1. Setup: A Bruel & Kjaer HATS (Head and Torso Simulator) Type 4128C is used - this equipment is generally considered to yield the most accurate measurements (built to the average torso and ears of people worldwide). It is also among the most expensive HAT Simulators.

 

2. Calibration: A correction must be made to take distortion due to the setup (such as shape of the ears) into account - in case of the Bruel & Kjaer Head and Torso Simulator Type 4128C, the equipment comes with a set of data to be used for calibration. At Golden Ears, the Diffuse Sound Field data provided by B&K is used in conjunction with the Room EQ characteristic (the distortion caused by the room when listening to speakers) from Etymotic Research to correct distortion.

 

3. Methodology: At Golden Ears, RTA(Real Time Analysis) is employed to check for fit (earphones and headphones) before we proceed with the actual measurements. If there are multiple earfoams, we measure and post data for each pair.

 

 

Q) Do you adjust your measurements, then?

A) You'll notice that earphones and headphones sound significantly different based on how they are worn - likewise, the measurements tend to change significantly. Users who visit GE are very surprised when they see the RTA data change so much before their eyes. There are several things that we could do about this:

 

1. Measure once and post

This is very inaccurate and unreliable.

 

2. Measure several times, and post all of them

While this method has the most relevance to real-life usage, the amount of data might be overwhelming for some.

 

3. Measure several times, and post the average

This would be the preferred method since it is fair and accurate, but unfortunately not too many softwares support averaging (ARTA used by GE also lacks this feature).

 

4. Using RTA to obtain optimal data

The Real Time Analyzer is able to process data as the signature (due to the fit) changes, and thus a single measurement with RTA is effectively several without. Furthermore, the RTA provides immediate feedback on how the fit impacts the sound, making it the best alternative.

 

At GE, the second and fourth methods are used.

 

 

Q) Is there a reason why GE does not publish raw data before corrections?

A) Raw data from each test product(earphones, headphones) varies depending on hardware (HATS or Artificial Ear) used to measure them. Thus, the raw data is useless even if it is published - this also means that you should not compare across websites or sources unless the data from both were calibrated using the same corrections. For instance, if two sets of data were calibrated using 'Diffuse Sound Field only', then it is possible to compare them to each other, though some difference might remain when comparing across sources.

 

 

Q) Shouldn't the acoustic impedance be calibrated differently for dynamic and balanced armature drivers?

A) Acoustic impedance is related to the structure and dimensions of the measuring equipment, and the relevant corrections are provided by the equipment manufacturer - also, the difference in the mode of operations (balanced armature or dynamic) does not necessarily mean that the calibration needs to be done differently.

In fact, if this were the case, Etymotic Research's ER-4Ps (which uses Balanced Armature) and MC5s (Dynamic) should have completely different trebles, which is not the case.

 

 

Q) I don't really know, but I've heard that GE's data is wrong sometimes.

A) As explained before, the discussion of audio measurements being 'wrong' and 'right' is in itself a show of ignorance - the unfortunate part is that the people who call us out usually have little understanding of how we measure, and frankly, it is difficult to understand where we are criticized. If you have any criticisms, please let us know in the Suggestions Forum so we may address it.

 

 

Q) Does it make me a GE Hater or Skeptic if I criticize or pose difficult questions?

A) Questions are always welcome - they are a necessary part of learning and furthermore the life and soul of science, which is what Golden Ears is about. Especially welcome are criticisms where the intent is to correct GE where it is wrong - all of us make mistakes, and corrections to these mistakes are essential to ensure that GE moves forward.

 

What we do not appreciate is the sort of dogmatic criticism that are hurled without sure knowledge or clearly defined points (for instance, regarding places where there is no clear cut line between right and wrong as in measurements).

 

 

Q) Are you an expert? What makes your data so reliable?

A) How would you define an 'expert'? What makes a website reliable?

If I proclaimed myself to be a 'master of measuring gifts', would that make me an expert? Or, would having a degree from a prestigious institution in the field of acoustics such as the ISVR make one an expert? As for the site itself, would it make GE more publicly credible if our net worth became larger than Microsoft? Would using more expensive equipment to measure establish credibility?

 

For some, the things listed above might be exactly what sets an expert and a trustworthy website apart from others; but I am sure that there are many more of us who believe that credibility is not established overnight merely by adhering to those things.

 

My belief is that if I continue to publish empirical, reproducible results with which more people could relate, and if my logic is convincing enough, I would be considered an expert, and that once more and more users find the similarities between the measured data in reviews and what they hear, Golden Ears would naturally gain credibility. :)

 

 

 Creative Commons License
Images, text and measured data by Golden Ears Corporation is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.

 

Golden Ears Test System - for more information (Link)
1. HATS: Bruel & Kjær - Head and Torso Simulator Type 4128C
2. Microphone Amplifier: Bruel & Kjær - NEXUS Conditioning Amplifier 
3. Audio Interface: Lynx L22
4. DAC: Golden Ears D/A Converter
5. Headphone Amplifier: Golden Ears Headphone Amplifier 

How we test
1. Headphone / Earphone
2. Speaker
3. Amplifier / DAP
 

How to read G.E. Graph
1. Earphone / Headphone
2. Speaker (Directivity Pattern)
3. DAP / Amplifier

Tag
Attachment

Comment '63'

profile

adam

2014.09.05 13:42
*.190.138.22
Your writing taste has been amazed me. Thank you, quite nice post
buy adderall online
profile

adam

2014.09.05 14:15
*.211.174.70
Really i appreciate the effort you made to share the knowledge.The
buy codeine online
topic here i found was really effective to the topic which i was researching for a long time
profile

adam1

2014.09.05 14:16
*.211.174.70
I just got to this amazing site not long ago. I was actually captured with the piece of resources you have got here. Big thumbs up for making such wonderful blog page!
buy lortab online
profile

Roshni

2018.06.20 19:37
*.249.123.22
NextJob portal is a revolution in the Human Resource Industry. It is going to change the traditional way of Talent Acquisition across the globe.

profile

NMK maha

2018.06.20 19:41
*.249.123.22

India's Recruitment for freshers. Govt, private all type of jobs .

NMK mha

profile

صيانة وايت ويل

2018.06.23 01:15
*.44.28.117

نقدم لكم افضل خدمات الصيانة المقدمة لكم من صيانة وايت ويل افضل مركز لصيانة الاجهزة الكهربائية على اعلى مستوى من الخبرة و الكفاءة فى التعامل مع كافة الاعطال التى قد تواجهكم كما نقدم لكم توكيل وايت ويل الافضل دائما فى تلبية احتياجاتكم و التى قد تصبح الضرورة الملحة لها لاتمام كافة عمليات الصيانة فى جميع محافظات مصر لاننا نهدف لارضاء عملائنا

http://www.whitewhaleg.com/

profile

صيانة سامسونج

2018.06.23 05:01
*.44.28.117

 لا يوجد منزل الان الا و بة جهاز على الاقل من اجهزة سامسونج المشهود لها بالكفاءة العالية على مدار السنين لذا وجب علينا توفير افضل خدمات صيانة سامسونج لصيانة جميع الاجهزة بالوسائل الحديثة فى اكتشاف العطال و العمل على سرعه حلها من خلال افضل فنيين الصيانة فى توكيل سامسونج بجميع انحاء الجمهورية و من خلال عربات الصيانة التى نوفرها لسهولة نقل الاجهزة اذا لزم الامر

http://www.samsung-maintenanceg.com/

profile

صصيانة يونيون اير

2018.06.24 01:33
*.44.13.6

لا داعى للقلق هذة الايام من اجهزة  يونيون اير المعطلة فى منازلكم و ذلك لاننا نوفر لكم فريق عمل مميز لاتمام كافة عمليات صيانة يونيون اير  على اعلى درجة من الخبرة و الكفاءة فى الاعتماد على الخبراء و الفنيين فى توكيل يونيون اير بجميع محافظات مصر و التى يقدم لكم كل جديد فى اجراء احدث عمليات الصيانة و اكتشاف كافة الاعطال

http://www.unionairemaintenance.com/

profile

صيانة اريستون

2018.06.24 04:27
*.44.13.6

نعمل على توفير افضل عمليات الصيانة المقدمة لكم من خلال صيانة اريستون و التى لا غنى عنها فى جميع المنازل لاعتماد افراد الصيانة على احدث الاساليب التكنولوجية الحديثة فى التعامل مع الاجهزة التى تريد صيانة من خلال توكيل اريستون الذى يوفر لكم جميع قطع الغيار المناسبة لكم و من خلال توفير الصيانة الدورية لكم على اعلى مستوى لضمان سلامة الاجهزة

http://www.ariston-maintenanceg.com/

profile

صيانة توشيبا

2018.06.24 05:13
*.44.13.6

مراكز صيانة توشيبا من اهم مراكز الصيانة الموجودة فى مصر لاتمام جميع عمليات الصيانة على اعلى مستوى من خلال خبراء الصيانة و المدربون على اكتشاف الاعطال باحدث الاساليب العلمية و العمل على سرعه حلها داخل توكيل توشيبا التى تجدوة فى جميع محافظات مصر كما نقدم لكم خدمة عملاء توشيبا الممتازة التى لا تقبل المنافسة لاننا نقدم كل جديد فى عالم الصيانة و على اعلى مستوى من الدقه فى العمل

http://www.toshiba-maintenance.com/

profile

صيانة كاريير

2018.06.24 06:38
*.44.13.6

نعمل على توفير كافة خبراء الصيانة فى توكيل كاريير لاتمام عمليات صيانة تكييفات كاريير بكل سهولة فى جميع محافظات مصر على اعلى مستوى و فى اقرب وقت ممكن من خلال خدمة عملاء كاريير المسئول لتوفير عربات الصيانة المتاحة لكم كما يتلقى استفساراتكم على مدار اليوم لان هدفنا الاول ارضاء العميل و تقديم افضل خدمة له و فى اسرع وقت ممكن

http://www.carrier-maintenance.com

profile

anod

2018.06.30 03:26
*.216.16.36

شركة العنود من أهم وأكبر شركات التنظيف شركة تنظيف كنب بالبخار بمكة ونقل الأثاث في المملكة العربية السعودية حيث انها شركة تنظيف سجاد بمكة شركة تنظيف كنب بالبخار بمكة بالبخار متخصصة في غسيل السجاد وتنظيفه بجميع خامته المختلفة وتعد ايضا اهم شركة تنظيف سجاد بالبخار بمكة حيث ان الشركة تضم فريق من العمالة المتدربة علي أحدث أساليب التنظيف وتقدم افضل الخدمات التي تحتاج اليها كثيرا

Maximum Attachments : 0Byte/ 10.00MB
Maximum File Size : 2.00MB (Allowed Extensions : *.*)

List of Articles
No. Subject Nick Name Date Views
  • Registered Date: Aug 09, 2011

40106

VIEWS

63

COMMENTED

  • Registered Date: Aug 08, 2011

93892

VIEWS

21

COMMENTED

  • Registered Date: Aug 08, 2011

67894

VIEWS

11

COMMENTED

  • Registered Date: Aug 08, 2011

137464

VIEWS

178

COMMENTED

  • Registered Date: Aug 08, 2011

64208

VIEWS

6

COMMENTED