Advertisement
Total Articles 13

02

2011-Sep

basic Cables & Sound Quality (Testing)

Nick Name: Golden Ears Registered Date: Sep 02, 2011, 03:05:50 IP ADRESS: *.56.123.5 Views: 25331

 

00.jpg

 

Setting up an audio chain consists of several choices: first, the analogue / digital audio source (CD, LP, MP3) must be chosen; then the source device (CDP, turntables, MP3 players) which converts the data to sound must be selected, followed by an amplifier, which amplifies the signal from the source device to suitable levels, and finally the speaker / earphones / headphones must be chosen to convert the elctrical signal to audible sound.

 

On the positive side, this represents a wide range of options for listening to music, but this may be a bit too much for novice audiophiles. In addition, there are other products that introduce further confusion - DACs, for instance, are sometimes mistaken in their function by new audiophiles. And one such product - and there is no shortage of confusion here - that we will be testing today is the cable.


For a theoretical discussion regarding cables, please refer to ''Cables & Sound Quality" - for those of you who are in a hurry, the conclusion is that 'unless the manufacturer has purposefully designed the cable to introduce distortion, the cables have little effect on the sound'.


For today, we'll look at how the sound of earphones change with different cables.

 


candidates.png

The candidates for today's testing are:


1. Ultimate Ears Default Cable
2. Ultimate Ears Custom Cable
3. Furetech Cable


I personally wanted to test the Lune cable as well, but unfortunately none were available for testing. If there is anyone out there who could perhaps lend the cable for a week to GE, then I'll be sure to review it as well.

01_Cable_01.jpg

From the left, Ultimate Ears Default Cable, Ultimate Ears Custom Cable, Furetech Cable


02_Cable_02.jpg

 From the left, Ultimate Ears Default Cable, Ultimate Ears Custom Cable, Furetech Cable


 

03_Cable_03.jpg

From the left, Ultimate Ears Default Cable, Ultimate Ears Custom Cable, Furetech Cable


 

04_Cable_04.jpg

From the left, Ultimate Ears Default Cable, Ultimate Ears Custom Cable, Furetech Cable

 

 

methology.png

The testing methodology is simple: the cables will be swapped on Ultimate Ears triple.fi (M-Audio IE40) earphones, and the frequency response will be compared. If the sound does change, then the frequency response should reflect this, and if it does not, then the frequency response graphs will be identical.

 


results.png

 

05_FR_Cable_Comparison.png

 

The result for the Furetech cable was almost identical to the stock cable within error, but the Ultimate Ears Custum Cable shows some discrepancy in the treble range (less treble compared to stock).


Due to its characteristic impedance curve, the Ultimate Ears triple.fi 10 pro has a treble presence that weakens with additional impedance. With this in mind, I thought that the cable might have a different impedance value, and voila:
(for a more in-depth discussion of how the sound changes as impedance is added, consult the article on output impedance and the impedance graph)

 

06_IG_Cable_Comparison.png

 

Measuring the impedance on various cables, it is clear that while the stock and the Furutech cables share a nearly identical impedance curve, the U.E. Custom Cable has a higher impedance (by about 5 ohms) compared to either. The likely explanation is that the manufacturer added some impedance to make the Custom Cable sound different, and this is the cause for the weaker treble.

 

 

Conclusion.png

We see that there is little difference in sound between cables that have not been specifically treated. In case of the U.E. Custom Cable, the slight change in sound is due to the cable's resistance, and the same effect could be acheived by adding a 5Ω resistor to the stock cables (or any other normal cable for that matter).


Note
5Ω of resistance is a huge value for a cable, and this is what causes me to believe that the manufacturer added it purposefully.
(Default, Furetech Cable : 0.07Ω / UE Custom Cable : 4.8Ω)
'High-end cables' might still have some advantages in other areas such as cable texture, finish and durabilities, but not in sound.

 


 

List of Articles
No. Subject Nick Name Date Views
  • Registered Date: Sep 08, 2011

34013

VIEWS

  • Registered Date: Sep 07, 2011

35926

VIEWS

  • Registered Date: Sep 07, 2011

21155

VIEWS

  • Registered Date: Sep 07, 2011

29059

VIEWS

  • Registered Date: Sep 02, 2011

26433

VIEWS

  • Registered Date: Sep 02, 2011

25331

VIEWS

  • Registered Date: Sep 01, 2011

36823

VIEWS

  • Registered Date: Sep 01, 2011

19830

VIEWS

  • Registered Date: Aug 25, 2011

30462

VIEWS

7

COMMENTED

  • Registered Date: Aug 09, 2011

21423

VIEWS

5

COMMENTED

  • Registered Date: Aug 09, 2011

43831

VIEWS

8

COMMENTED

  • Registered Date: Aug 09, 2011

40451

VIEWS

9

COMMENTED

  • Registered Date: Aug 09, 2011

59457

VIEWS

14

COMMENTED